Jacques-Louis de Bougrenet de la Tocnaye wrote in 1797:
The Shannon is not navigable, properly speaking, above Limerick; its course is thereafter often interrupted by rocks and cascades through which a plank could hardly pass in safety. To make navigation possible there have been cut, lately, certain canals making connection between those parts of the river which are deep enough for boats. One of these canals, a mile long, ends at Limerick, and in its short course there is a fall of not less than thirty feet. Boats can only ascend, by the locks, at a suitable time of tide, which here rises or falls from twelve to fifteen feet, although the town is sixty miles from the mouth of the river. One or two miles higher up, there is another canal, newly-finished, joining the river seven or eight miles from Castle Connell […].
If you examine the online Ordnance Survey Historic 6″ map for the Plassey area of Limerick, you’ll notice an oddity. Here’s the relevant bit.
You’ll see that there is a ferry from the north bank to the middle of the river and what looks like a bridge from the south bank almost, but not quite, meeting it.
The later (Historic 25″) map, from around 1900, shows the bridge stretching all the way across.
I refer to these two editions as the ~1840 and ~1900 editions, but of course different areas were surveyed, and the maps printed, at different times over the course of several years. The north bank at Plassey, which is in Co Clare, was surveyed before the south, which is in Co Limerick, and the bridge was built in the interval.
Plassey is now the site of the University of Limerick, part of the suburb of Castletroy. It is the junction between two of the five sections of the (now-abandoned) Limerick Navigation, which connected Limerick and the sea to Lough Derg and thence to Dublin. The next map shows, at bottom left, the Park Canal from Limerick; from its upper (right-hand, on the map) end the navigation passed into the River Shannon, which curved south and north in a large S. Then, around the centre of the map, you can see the straight line of the third section of the navigation, the Plassey–Errina Canal, heading north-eastward away from the river. It avoided the Falls of Doonass and rejoined the river downstream of O’Briensbridge.
Before the bridge
Downstream of Plassey, the boatstream and the trackway (towing-path) are on the south (left-when-facing-downstream) bank of the river, but the Plassey–Errina Canal departs from the north bank. So a boat travelling from Limerick to Killaloe, at the southern end of Lough Derg, has to cross the Shannon, while the force of the current tries to sweep it downstream.
In the days before engines, boatmen had nothing but muscle power and ingenuity to help them across. It was probably difficult enough when the water level and current were low, but practically impossible when they were high.
Although the Limerick Navigation Company was set up in 1767, the first traffic was not until 1799, and that was only ten boats, carrying 15–20 tons each of non-urgent cargoes including corn, slate and turf. No towing-path was provided at first; boats were man-hauled on the Park Canal (as it is now called) and sailed or rowed on the river section.
The difficulty of crossing the Shannon at Plassey was recognised. It seems that John Brownrigg, engineer to the Directors-General of Inland Navigation, had considered laying a chain across the river so that crews could haul their boats over; Francis Trench, in a report in 1805, did not consider this a satisfactory solution, but he did praise Brownrigg for having turned the course of the River Blackwater (which joins the Shannon alongside the Plassey–Errina Canal) so that it no longer created shoals at the entrance to the canal.
The OSI map of ~1840 shows some buoys in the river; they may have been used in getting boats across the river.
A towing-path was eventually built along the river sections, but it was not entirely satisfactory. In evidence to the Select Committee on the Shannon Navigation on 14 July 1834, Charles Wye Williams said:
[…] it is so high and narrow that the horses often fall off it. […] It is [subject to inundation], so much so that there is often a sea upon both sides of the high-raised bank, and during last winter a large portion of it was swept away; the whole bank was covered with three feet of water, so that we were obliged to send men with sticks leading the horses, and feeling their way on the banks. […] There is no way of improving it. […] It could be widened, but at great expense.
Boats, passengers and horses had to be transferred from one side of the river to the other. It might have been possible to use different horses on the far side, avoiding the need to ship them across, but the Parliamentary Gazetteer of 1846 suggests that they were transported:
PLASSEY, a locality in the parish of Kiltonanlea, barony of Lower Tulla, co. Clare, 2 miles north-east of Limerick, Munster. Here the rivulet Blackwater falls into the Shannon, the long stretch of the Limerick navigation within Clare commences, and a foot bridge across the Shannon was proposed to be constructed by the Commissioners for improving the Shannon Navigation. The horses employed in tracking boats up the Limerick navigation pass at Plassey from the left to the right bank of the Shannon, and used formerly to be conveyed across in boats, a method occasioning both inconvenience and delay; and the chief design of the foot bridge is to afford for the horses facility of passage. Estimated cost, £3,000.
Thomas Rhodes, surveying the Limerick Navigation for the first set of Shannon Commissioners in 1832, wrote of Plassey:
Great inconvenience is felt from the want of a foot-bridge to cross from Plassey Mill to Annaghbeg Lock, for the purpose of towing the packet-boats and trading vessels: at present a ferry-boat is employed for the purpose of taking horses and passengers across the river. The velocity of the current at this place has been ascertained this winter, and found to run at the rate of three miles per hour; width of river, 450 feet. Passengers have been obliged frequently to get out of the packet-boat, and be ferried across in the small boat; and trading vessels have been cast ashore on the bank below, and under the necessity of unloading the cargo into other craft for the purpose of getting off; this is highly dangerous to lives and property. At present a buoy is anchored in the centre of the river, and in times of a flood trading vessels are obliged to run out a cable or warp to this buoy to swing clear of the north bank; and when this is accomplished, they run another warp to the south side to haul them across: this method causes great delay.
I am credibly informed that foot passengers alone, who are in the habit of crossing here, would pay the interest of a bridge; but for the improvement of the navigation alone, I consider a bridge absolutely necessary, and therefore I have now a plan and estimate in preparation for it.
This suggests that a ferry boat was kept at Plassey for passengers. In 1815 Patrick Curtis, at Ferry House, Plassy, earned a half-year salary of £7/10/=.
It is not clear how trading vessels would run a cable to a buoy during a flood; it would make more sense to have the cable permanently attached and to use the force of the current to swing the boat across the river. Kevin Hannan [PDF] says that winches were used. I will continue to seek evidence and would welcome further information.
Thomas Rhodes’s bridge
The second set of Shannon Commissioners drew up plans for the various works. Rhodes designed the bridge to be erected at Plassey. Here are two poor photographs of parts of the plans.
The third set of Shannon Commissioners carried out the work. In their third report, for 1841, they wrote:
This work is considerably advanced; the excavations for the abutments have been completed, and all the bearing piles driven, together with the cappings fixed on them ready to receive the masonry; the filling in of the concrete between the piles has also been completed.
All the main piles for supporting the girders, plates for the roadway, &c, have been driven, and the timber and iron cappings fixed on them.
The whole of the iron work, consisting of girders, fascia and roadway plates, &c, has been delivered on the works, ready to be fixed; consequently this bridge will be completed within a short time.
The average number of persons employed daily upon this work, from its commencement on the 3rd May up to the 31st December 1841, was 12, being equivalent to 2,461 days’ work.
The following year, in their fourth report, the Commissioners wrote:
This bridge has been completed, and independent of the advantages which it affords to the traders for passing horses employed in towing the boats, the public have been allowed to use it, instead of being ferried over in a barge as formerly; it is now much used by the country people who attend the markets in Limerick, or who have business to transact there.
By a Return furnished to the Commissioners, it appears that between the 20th and 27th December 4,161 passengers and 76 horses have crossed over this bridge.
The average number of persons employed daily at Plassey Bridge, from the 25th April to the 17th September, was 27, being equivalent to 3,362 days’ work.
In the same report, the Commissioners made an interesting point:
[…] In consequence of the erection of Plassey Bridge, it became necessary to change the trackway from the north to the southern bank of the canal between Annaghbeg Lock and the first bridge above it; this was effected for a trifling expense, and thereby did away with the necessity for having a bridge across the canal below the lock.
That change is reflected on the OSI map from ~1900:
Kevin Hannan wrote:
Trippers to Plassey are often puzzled by the milestone mid-way between the bridge and the garrison wall. This stone bears the inscription: ‘Limerick 2 miles; Killaloe 12 miles’, and up stream from the canal track, people are bewildered by its positlon. This circumstance is a reminder of the days before the erection of Plassey Bridge, when the towing horses were ferried across the river on a special raft which was winched from one side to the other. […] The building of Plassey Bridge saw the end of this difficult, and dangerous operation. The milestones were erected between Limerick and Killaloe, in 1814, and marked the mileage both ways. The distances were set out in Irish miles.
I don’t know whether the milestone is in its original position. If it is, it might be possible to work out something about the ferry system by seeing whether an isosceles triangle, with its apex at the position of one of the buoys marked on the ~1840 OSI map, would touch the presumed launching point near the milestone and the northern (downstream) bank of the Plassey–Errina Canal.
The tow-ropes of the barges
The bridge made it easier for horses to get across the river; it did nothing to reduce the power of the current. Nowadays, most of the Shannon’s flow is diverted through the hydroelectric power station at Ardnacrusha, which gets the first 400 cubic metres per second of water; the old course of the river, through Plassey, gets only 10, unless Ardnacrusha has more than it wants, although it does get extra water from tributaries like the Mulcair. Ardnacrusha has also had the effect of reducing seasonal variation in water level along the old navigation, and it is only in extreme conditions that we get any idea of the amount of water that formerly came through Plassey. Such conditions occurred in November 2009, when the photo above was taken (see more pics of that period here, here and here).
The bridge meant that the horse was not subject to the force of the current — but the barge or lumber-boat was. As the horse walked across, the barge was more and more exposed to that force, pushing it downstream; the strain on gear, ropes and horses must have been considerable.
That strain can be felt on the parapet of the bridge: the stonework on the Annaghbeg side bears grooves worn into it by the tow-ropes. The grooves are almost impossible to see (and I wouldn’t have known about them but that An tOllamh Breandán Ó Madagáin told me about them) but you can feel them with your fingers. I put pens in some of the grooves so that they would show up in the photos below.
I am told that rope-marks can also be seen on the metal rails of the bridge, but I have no photos of them.
Rope marks on bridge abutments or piers are relatively common; marks on the parapets are rare. I have seen no description of a crossing of the river at this point; it would be interesting to know how horses and their human drivers dealt with the strain.
The floods of 2009
The navigation was abandoned when the Ardnacrusha power station was opened. However, it was still owned by the state (Office of Public Works, as successor to the Shannon Commissioners), and in 1949 Limerick County Council leased it. It made some repairs to the bridge at that time.
Sixty years later, in 2009, Plassey was flooded.
The black bridge, which usually stands well clear of the water …
… had water almost up to its deck and debris caught against it.
The County Council feared that the bridge had been weakened; it closed the bridge. It has not been able to afford to repair it properly.
The Council can argue that walkers, including those following the Lough Derg Way, can use the University of Limerick’s road bridge just upstream; it has a separated section for walkers and cyclists.
Someone walking from Limerick to Gillogue would have to go a little further upstream, to reach the university’s bridge, then back downstream on the far side to reach the Plassey–Errina Canal’s towing-path. It is certainly true, then, that in practical terms the bridge’s closure is not a great inconvenience.
The significance of the bridge
But that is to miss entirely the significance of the bridge. It is not, of course, surprising that it should be missed: as far as I know, there is not a single signboard, plaque or even document that calls attention to the historic importance of this bridge and of the route of which it was part.
The key question is why the government of Her Late Majesty Victoria, by the Grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland Queen, spent half a million pounds in the 1840s improving the navigation of the Shannon, including building the bridge at Plassey. There are several aspects to the answer, but one of them is that the work was undertaken to prevent food shortages.
The work was planned long before the Great Famine, although as it happened much of it was carried out during that catastrophe and provided employment and income for many men. But at the planning stage, the industrial revolution meant that Britain was producing only five sixths of the food it needed. Ireland, on the other hand, was able to produce a surplus, because its staple, the potato, was so nutritious. And steam technology provided a means of transporting that surplus to the markets of Liverpool and Manchester.
Steamers on the Shannon Estuary carried passengers, but also livestock, up to Limerick. Horse-drawn barges carried cargoes of food onward up the old Limerick Navigation to Killaloe, where steamers took over the tow (and picked up more cargoes) up Lough Derg to Portumna. Smaller steamers towed the barges up to Shannon Harbour, whence they were towed by horse along the Grand Canal to Dublin. From there, they went by steamer to Liverpool and, some of them, on further to Manchester.
The ramshackle, badly designed, badly built Limerick Navigation was the link between the west coast of Ireland and the cross-country route to Dublin and thence to Liverpool. Charles Wye Williams took over the navigation in order to improve it and to get his boats through; his name is on Baal’s Bridge in Limerick, which as far as I know is his only public monument. But the government decided to take over and improve the whole of the Shannon and, throughout the 1830s, it carried out surveys and drew up plans which it implemented during the 1840s.
The Black Bridge at Plassey was part of that work. When cargoes were of non-perishable goods (turf, stone, timber, corn, slate), a delay at Plassey, while waiting for water levels to subside, did not very much matter. But once the west coast of Ireland became integrated with the UK economy, the arrival of the regular cargoes of food became much more important, as did the safe and speedy movement of passengers: the navigation became part of the most comfortable route from London to Killarney and elsewhere in the west of Ireland.
The navigation has an extraordinary wealth of transport heritage: seven of the original milestones along the twelve-mile route (an Irish mile is about 1.25 statute miles or 2 km), many of the characteristic accommodation bridges, locks, pins for ropes, the capstan at O’Briensbridge, the marble mill and the Pierhead in Killaloe … all part of a historic trail. It helped to built the Irish livestock trade. It has close links with Liverpool, in particular, not only because the food went there but because five of the first six iron vessels built by Lairds of Birkenhead were built for the Shannon. It is also closely linked with the City of Dublin Steam Packet Company and the P&O Line. And the 1840s improvements came about because Ireland’s greatest ever transport entrepreneur, Charles Wye Williams, had shown what could be done.
It might be hard to justify spending money on the bridge for the convenience of locals of both counties, but this is the centrepiece of what could be a major tourism attraction. The Limerick Navigation should be branded as an industrial heritage walking route, not just as an anodyne “Lough Derg Way”, and should be marketed as the focus of weekend and week-long visits to the area. The bridge is the vital link between the Limerick and Clare parts of the navigation.
There are some more reminiscences of Plassey here; googling will find more.
Charlotte Murphy “The Limerick Navigation Company, 1697–1836” in North Munster Antiquarian Journal Vol XXII Thomond Archaeological Society 1980
Jacques-Louis de Bougrenet de la Tocnaye A Frenchman’s Walk through Ireland 1796–7 (translated by John Stevenson), McCaw, Stevenson & Orr Ltd The Linenhall Press, Belfast and Hodges Figgis & Co Ltd Dublin 1917
The Parliamentary Gazetteer of Ireland […] 1844–45 A Fullarton & Co, Dublin, London and Edinburgh 1846
Kevin Hannan “Memories of the old canal” in Old Limerick Journal Vol 7 Summer 1981
Thomas Rhodes Report upon Canal and River Navigation from Limerick to Killaloe 28 February 1832
Various reports of the Shannon Commissioners